I Paid $35 for 50 Pinterest Pins. Here’s What My Traffic Looked Like After

A pinterest pin design service was not something I planned on paying for. I figured pin design was a Canva problem, not a money problem. Pick a template, swap the photo, change the text, done. I did that for almost a year before I admitted the pins themselves might be the reason my traffic had gone flat.

What my pins actually looked like

Grid of similar-looking Pinterest pins with the same font, colors, and layout, next to a list of problems: same font, same three colors, same layout, not enough variety, low click-through rate, alongside Pinterest analytics showing 432.6k impressions but only 1.2k outbound clicks

Same font every time. Same three colors because they were the ones already saved in my Canva brand kit. Same layout, headline on top, photo underneath, every single time. Pinterest was showing my pins to people, the impressions were fine, but almost nobody clicked through. I kept blaming the algorithm. It took me an embarrassingly long time to consider that the pins themselves just were not good enough to earn a click.

Why I finally looked for help

A reader in a Facebook group I’m part of mentioned she used a Fiverr seller for her pin design and her saves had picked up noticeably. I was skeptical, mostly because $35 felt too cheap to be real design work. But I was also tired of staring at Canva at 11pm trying to make the same five templates look different, so I sent over five of my blog posts, my brand colors, and a rough idea of what I wanted.

What came back two days later

Fifty pins. Actual variation between them, not just a recolored version of the same layout. Text placement that changed depending on the image instead of being locked to the same corner every time. They looked like something from a design agency, not a $35 gig, and that was the first moment I thought this might actually be worth repeating.

What happened after I scheduled them

I loaded all fifty into my scheduler the same week and let them run alongside my existing pins so I could actually compare performance. Within a month my Pinterest traffic was up 340%. Two of those fifty pins are still, right now, my top referral sources on the entire site. I have not designed a pin myself since, and I do not plan to start again.

4.9 · 1,203 reviews · Fiverr Pro

What you actually get for $35

  • 50 custom pins matched to your exact brand colors and fonts, not a generic template pack
  • Sized and formatted for Pinterest’s current 2:3 ratio, so nothing gets cropped or flagged
  • Delivered in 48 hours, so you are not waiting weeks for a batch of graphics
  • Editable source files included, so you can tweak text yourself for future posts
  • No monthly retainer, no subscription, just one flat rate for the full batch
See the exact pin design service I used
This seller caps new orders at 8 per week to keep turnaround at 48 hours. When I last checked, 5 of those 8 slots were already booked for this week.
Fiverr buyer protection 30-day cookie Trending now

A few questions readers ask me about this

Do I need to know Canva or Photoshop to use this?

No. The seller works from your blog posts, photos, and brand colors, and sends back finished pins. The editable files are there if you want to tweak something later, but you do not need any design skill to get started.

Will 50 pins actually last me a while?

For most bloggers, yes. Fifty pins covers roughly 10 posts at five pin variations each, which is enough to test what design style performs best before ordering another batch.

What if I do not like the first batch?

Fiverr’s buyer protection covers this. In my experience, sending a clear example of the style you want up front avoids most revision requests entirely.

Leave a Comment

Get 30% off your first purchase

Close Welcome Bar